THE BJ-LEAGUE INSIDER
  • Basketball Writer in Japan blog
  • 2014-15 team rosters
  • 2014-15 import players
  • 2014-15 season - by the numbers
  • Archived stories in The Japan Times
  • A look at the league's foreign coaches
  • What others are saying
  • Useful hoop sites in Japanese
  • (Through 2010-11 season) Top players in bj-league history: An in-depth analysis and survey
  • Year-by-year team involvement
  • 2012-13 Import players' college list
  • 2012-13 rosters
  • 2011-12 team rosters
  • 2011-12 foreign players and coaches list
  • Former NBA players' update
  • An introduction to the bj-league
  • Thought of the day
  • Memorable quotes
  • Media gets a raw deal
  • A source of inspiration
  • Interviews
  • Cost-cutting measures hurt league's image
  • The top Japanese rebounder is ...
  • The reality is ...
  • Respect for his peers
  • Best Five teams - 2005-06 to present
  • By the numbers
  • Not good enough
  • Poignant comments
  • JBL vs. bj-league and the problems both face
  • The way it is
  • Kawachi's impact
  • More memorable quotes
  • Photo gallery

Commentary: The coming season

9/3/2012

1 Comment

 
I'm an optimist by nature, and always try to see the glass as half full. But I have little confidence that those running the bj-league know what they are doing. Nor do I believe that they are guiding the league in the right direction. 
 
The 2012-13 season, for example, will feature a wacky rule that requires teams to use two imports in the first and third quarters. Forget about logic and having the normal flow of the game determine which five players a coach puts on the floor. Nope, not in the bj-league. Forget about real coaching; that won't be allowed based on this momentum-suffocating requirement. 
 
A mathematical formula will require teams to have a maximum 2/5ths of their lineup consist of imports for half a game and for the second and fourth quarters that number can be three imports per team, or 3/5ths of their on-court performers. 

Does that make sense to you? I doubt it.
 
Is half the game more important than the other half? No. 
 
But that's the message the league office has forced teams to abide by. 
 
With nonstop expansion (six teams in 2005-06 to 21 for the 2012-13 campaign) for nearly a decade now in a country that lags behind nearly the entire the world in terms of quality basketball players, there is no realist who'll tell you there are enough good Japanese players to suddenly make a greater impact for half the game throughout the season. (This is doing the Japanese pros a disservice, in fact; as the only way Japanese will continue to get better is by facing the best possible competition as often as possible. And that better competition happens to be the imports in the league.) 
 
Quality of play is not the reason for change, of course. It's a cost-cutting measure. (Many teams will now pay the salary of four imports instead of five. The investment on more foreign players, though, is the right one, one that would help the league continue to get better quality Japanese players and better overall competition, day in and day out.)
 
But is the financial savings going to put more fans in the stands? 
 
Is that going to give the league more revenue? 
 
Is that going to create a much-needed rise in national media coverage? 
 
I hate to say I told you so, but the answers are: No, no, no. 
 
Don't expect the bj-league to have better games this season. Each game will be a game within a game, when three Japanese are required on the floor for each team 50 percent of the time, and the other 50 percent when only two must be there. 
 
Professional athletes need to earn playing time by being, well, good enough to play whenever a coach puts them into the game, and puts them into the game without an absurd pre-determined quota. 
 
By the way, this new rule, an extension of the lousy second-quarter only quota in place for the past two seasons, will also reduce the statistics of many players. Players want to win, they also want to dominate stat categories. 
 
More than a few players will be turned off by the above rule and take their game to another country, knowing they won't post the "big stats" that may get them attention for a shot to play in a big-time league or, you never know, earn a tryout for an NBA team. 

Comissioner Toshimitsu Kawachi's league has made a terrible mistake by instituting this rule. That's obvious.

 
 
 
   
1 Comment
Lee Tao Dana
9/13/2012 07:11:19 pm

I found your post VERY interesting. I've been thinking for a while now about going back to Japan (spent 3 years teaching there) and maybe helping a bj-league team. I met Bob Hill while working for the Idaho Stampede in the NBA Development League and thought since I love basketball AND Japan why not coach or work for a pro team in Japan? But your story makes me think, wow, they really do need help in the bj-league with this new rule. Well, I still plan to head over soon but wonder how things will turn out. Since some players won't be able to fill the stat sheets they way they would like they will without question have to bolt for greener pastures and that will surely weaken the overall talent in the league. It's going to be interesting.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Ed Odeven

    I'm a sports writer, columnist and editor for The Japan Times.
    This site is an extension of my work covering the bj-league. News, commentary, notes, quotes and anecdotes about the bj-league.

    Archives

    April 2015
    March 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011

    Categories

    All
    2011-12 Season
    89ers
    Afl
    Akita
    Al Davis
    All-Star Games
    Aoki
    Bad Attendance
    Bj League
    Bj-league
    Blocked Shots
    Bob Hill
    Bob Pierce
    Broncos
    Cancer Survivor
    Champion Head Coaches
    Chiba Jets
    Coach Blackwell
    Coaches
    Coach Gardow
    Coaching Carousel
    Cohey Aoki
    Constant Chaos
    David Benoit
    Debuts
    Dwane Casey
    Earthquake
    Eastern Conference
    Eric Gardow
    Evessa
    Fan Donations
    Fan Perspective
    Final Four
    Fukuoka
    Gardener
    Geoffrey Katsuhisa
    Gimmicks
    Golden Kings
    Great East Japan Earthquake
    Hamamatsu
    Happinets
    Heatdevils
    Herb Brown
    Hernando Planells
    Holm
    Home Page
    Honoo Hamaguchi
    Humphrey
    Itakura
    Iwate Big Bulls
    Japan Basketball Association
    Japan Women's National Team
    Jbl
    Jeff Newton
    Jeffrey Parmer
    J.League
    John Flowers
    Johnny Dukes
    Joho
    Katakana
    Kazuo Nakamura
    Kyoto Hannaryz
    Lance Allred
    Lawrence Blackledge
    League Operations
    League Promotions
    Lynn Washington
    Magic Johnson
    Mahmoud Abdul-Rauf
    Maki
    Management Ability
    March 11
    Media Problems
    Michael Gardener
    Michael Jackson
    Michael Jordan
    Michael Katsuhisa
    Miyazaki
    Motofumi Aoki
    Nakama
    Nakamura
    Nakanishi
    Namizato
    Narito Namizato
    Natalie Nakase
    Nba Lockout
    Neumann
    New Teams
    Nfl
    Nhk
    Oita
    Okinawa Fans
    One-year Anniversary Of Earthquake
    Osaka
    Osaka Evessa
    Parity
    Parker
    Peppers
    Phil Jackson
    Photos
    Poetry
    Poor Pr
    Pr
    Rashaad Singleton
    Reggie Geary
    Ryan Blackwell
    Ryukyu
    Ryukyu Golden Kings
    Saitama
    Saitama Broncos
    Sendai
    Sendai 89ers
    Shiga Lakestars
    Shinji Tomiyama
    Sportcourt
    Statistics
    Takamatsu
    Takamatsu Five Arrows
    Takehiko Shimura
    Takushi
    Tanaka
    Thomas
    Tohoku
    Tokyo Cinq Reves
    Tomohide Utsumi
    Top 10 Scorers
    Top Japanese Players
    Toshimitsu Kawachi
    Vlasios Vlaikidis
    Washington
    Wendell White
    Yokohama
    Yokohama B Corsairs
    Yokohama B-Corsairs
    Yu Okada
    Yuta Tabuse

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.